My icemaker has quit working. I look up the replacement and get back part # PS358591 for $109.74. I then look up "Add on ice maker kit" and get back part # PS317560 for $99.40. The ice maker unit appears to be the same! Why would I spend $109.74 when it looks like I can get the unit I need for $99.40?
Sheila,
Thanks for the response! Now I'm wondering what might be in the replacement kit that is not in the add on kit that would justify the 10% price increase of the replacement vs the add on?
I notice the quiet difference too. One for $109.95 is for replacement, and for $99.95 was for a new kit, which has water valve, hose, mounting kits, etc about $45 in extra parts yet, it is about 10% cheaper. I wonder who priced it?
Replacement Ice Maker - Whirlpool 
